I never finished the crab shack because of requirements, so I'm trying this one.
Ok, so I bought 3 gold nets to guarantee my catches. I had enough fuel to go to Basker's Haven island. With 3 nets and 3 turtles there, I thought I could get all at once, but after I captured two of them, it sent my boat back. Why? I figured you should save up your fuel and nets to be able to do it all at once. No?
Zynga Support: https://zyngasupport.helpshift.com/a/zyngagames-com/